AMCH Withdraws Marriage Advisory, But Questions Over HOD’s Accountability Continue
The Assam Medical College and Hospital's controversial advisory asking postgraduate trainees to defer personal milestones has been withdrawn following public debate, but social media reactions are now questioning whether the decision is sufficient and calling for accountability.

DIBRUGARH- The withdrawal of a controversial advisory asking postgraduate trainees at Assam Medical College and Hospital (AMCH), Dibrugarh, to defer marriage and other personal milestones during their residency tenure has failed to put an end to the debate, with public reactions now shifting towards questions of accountability and the working environment within the department.
The Department of Medicine at AMCH issued a fresh office order on November 18, withdrawing its earlier directive, numbered MED/2026/5700, which had triggered widespread discussion over institutional authority and the personal freedom of medical trainees.
The withdrawal was confirmed through an official communication by the Chief Minister’s Office, Assam, on its X account. The post stated that the Department of Medicine had withdrawn the earlier office order with immediate effect.
Also Read- Marriage Can Wait? AMCH Order Asking Medical Trainees to Defer Marriage Sparks Debate
The fresh notification, signed by Prof. Prasanta Dhingia, Professor and Head of the Department of Medicine, explicitly stated that the previous advisory stood cancelled and should be treated as withdrawn from the date of issuance of the notice.
However, reactions following the announcement indicate that the controversy has moved beyond the withdrawal itself.
Several users on social media have questioned whether cancelling the advisory is sufficient or whether further accountability is necessary.
Dr. Prarit Varshney, commenting on the development on X, said that retracting the order was not enough and questioned whether someone holding such views should continue in a position of authority.
Also Read- Two Artists with Nepali Roots Draw Attention in Salman Khan’s Maatrubhumi
Another commenter, using the account name RCB, alleged that although the advisory had been withdrawn on paper, postgraduate trainees might continue to face informal restrictions within the department. The commenter suggested that trainees could be reluctant to challenge the Head of Department.
Other users also questioned whether any action was being initiated against the Head of Department. Some went further, demanding his removal from the position.
These reactions reflect a section of the online discussion that considers the issue larger than the withdrawal of a written directive. Questions are now being raised about institutional accountability, the treatment of resident doctors and the extent to which personal decisions of postgraduate trainees should fall within the authority of departmental heads.
Importantly, the claim that an informal restriction may continue despite the official withdrawal remains an allegation raised in a public comment and has not been independently established.
The original advisory had sparked debate because it concerned personal milestones, including marriage, during the residency tenure of postgraduate trainees in the Department of Medicine. While professional responsibilities, patient care and academic commitments are integral to medical training, the controversy raised questions about the boundaries between institutional discipline and individual personal freedom.
The latest development has therefore created two distinct questions: whether the formal withdrawal of the advisory resolves the immediate controversy, and whether the concerns surrounding the department’s working environment and administrative accountability require further examination.
As of November 19, the available withdrawal order confirms the cancellation of the earlier advisory. However, it does not mention any disciplinary action against the Head of Department or explain the reasons behind the withdrawal.
The controversy now leaves a larger question for the medical institution: is withdrawing the disputed order enough to restore confidence among postgraduate trainees, or are further steps needed to address the concerns that brought the issue into public discussion?









